Bad News for Nannies (Except Mine)

December 11, 2008

The New York times tells me that the financial crisis is having new effects: on nannies and housekeepers (chimney-sweeps included).  Amongst New York professionals who are facing job losses and economic uncertainy, there is increasing pressure to cut back on domestic help.  Thus the crisis seems to have spread quickly from the financial economy to the real economy and then down to the blackmarket economy, where most nannies, housekeepers and other domestic help is hired and paid.

I’ve written elsewhere on the political economy of nannies in London, before I had one myself.   The wages of London nannies were reported (at that time) to be on average £33,000 a year, though having now entered the market, I can see that that average was massively thrown off by the full-time, live-in nannies of the uber-rich.  I imagine that nannies working in those type of positions, who are primarily employed for people working in the finance industry, might be at risk of cut-backs or job loss.  But amongst those of us that compromise the “normal nanny demand pool” the crisis has no effect on our provision of childcare.  Childcare has an inelastic demand curve as there are no suitable alternative replacements and our demand doesn’t weeken even if our economic future becomes more uncertain, unless of course we cease to have a demand because we lose our jobs and have to stay at home.

If anything, the financial crisis has increased my demand for childcare, not decreased it.  I find myself busier than ever, but maybe that’s because we work in a counter-cyclical industry, where student numbers and demand for consultancy tend to go up when crises hit.   Fortunately, that means that I don’t have to face the kind of hard choices the people in the New York Times article are facing, and neither does our (absolutely fantastic) nanny.


3 Responses to “Bad News for Nannies (Except Mine)”

  1. […] the industries in which they work will be strongly affected by the crisis: domestic service (people cut back on nannies, cleaners and other additional staff when times get bad), restaurants, construction, etc.   As […]

  2. […] now, his exposure to the two languages is about even despite the fact that we live in London, as our nanny is Italian and he sees both sides of our families often.  This is generally the strategy that is […]

  3. […] for this).   Those of us who are less famous, can write silly posts about eating breakfast and our nannies without fear of damaging our reputations (much […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: